Tags

Most of the developed countries are racking their brains out on how to resolve damaging climate change without lowering economic growth. The big boys in town want of course our economies to keep growing with an ever increasing supply of energy for ever increasing goodies by an ever increasing number of people. The engine of materialism has to be kept oiled even if it is killing us.
Economic frugality is the bane of western capitalism with economies that rely on growth rather than shrinkage, always pretending as if none of us live in a finite world. We hear murmurings of renewable energy, responsible emission targets for the future, but precious little on lowering our energy use, lowering our consumption, lowering the world’s obsession with economic growth. Yet, this seems to be far more logical.
Generally, if you are crook you take it easy. Not, it seems, with an economy though. You ramp it up, give it a couple of fiscal shots and hope it will all pan out. In the meantime the world is getting hotter, but so what; much of it is all a bit temporary anyway.
How capable are western countries in living frugally, or, more importantly, how will the population take to reducing energy consumption, reducing water, reduce our large houses, car size, income, standards of living, reduce spending? Some will argue that to save the world ecology we need to reign in economic growth and perhaps, if not voluntary, the ‘economic shrinkage’ will force itself on us, almost as part of a natural selection and survival of the fittest.
While there are many claiming that they have missed out on the fortunes of ever increasing material wellbeing, there are also many that have more than benefitted from wealth. In blatant terminal material societies such as ours and most other OECD’s, there are indeed many having missed out and live miserable lives while others are floating on a warm sea of obscene wealth.
We can’t hide behind the fact that we, per capita, are the world’s largest polluters. The gall to point at countries such as India and China as being the worst is a mean trick conjured up by fat moguls, belching from riches and internal dollar bloat.
The times ahead will be most interesting if not very hard for many people. The idea of forever increasing growth and ever increasing profits and wealth might be of the past. Sustainability and environmental concerns will have to override economies that have become obsolete on ‘growth ideology’ while remaining blind to the world’s survival… A far more equitable sharing of the pie to others must come about. Time is running out and no way will the capitalistic methods of the survival of the richest and most cunning solve a world close to a climatic death throe. The cult of individual effort and winner take all, ought to get much more scrutiny.
In the meantime the world is getting hotter.
Sorry it’s taken me so long to get round to reading this Gerard. It’s a good article and one which echoes my own thinking on the subject. The problem with capitalism is that it depends on an ever-increasing market for it to work at all; a bit like a ponzi or pyramid scheme really… and if we are to solve the climate problem at all, it’s going to require that we start doing things differently; sadly I don’t think this is likely to happen; as you say, we’ve got to keep the economy growing even if it’s killing us…
There’s a book by Michael Moorcock called, ‘Dancers at the End of Time’; it’s a wonderful and prophetic work really, which uses a science-fiction/fantasy tale to describe the current human predicament, although I first read it in the 1970s. If you can manage to find a copy of it in your library (or else at a secondhand bookshop!) I’m sure you would get a lot out of it…
😉
😉
LikeLike
So you can read now? Now you tell me 🙂
LikeLike
testing, testing
LikeLike
So did it work?
LikeLike
yo, it’s working again, HOO, I remembered my original email address, it’ s all fine and dandy, and even the annoying baby photo is back.
LikeLike
Is that why your gravatar didn’t appear? Not that I’m a pedant…
LikeLike
Maybe Mulga is right, something drastic has to happen, the bubble has to burst, the whole thing has to collapse, and after that we (whoever is still here) have to start from the scratch.
The starting from the scratch actually appeals to me. Being in transit, making do with less, is invigorating. Life is simpler, cleaner, less cluttered…
Bloody Hell, I’ll leave everything in boxes and take the whole darn lot to Smith Family,( or shall I take a rain check on that one…)
LikeLike
Helvi, starting from scratch could be a dangerous proposition.
LikeLike
yo, HOO, one might have to eat too much of the scratch mix, my chooks got fed up with it after a while…
LikeLike
yo helvasious, One wonders what One would have to put up with?
LikeLike
Sorry G that it’s taken me so long to read and respond to this thoughtful piece. You’re absolutely right of course. The only viable future is one where we’ve managed to reduce, reuse and recycle just about everything, including our notions regarding the meaning and purpose of “growth”.
Paramount among these “reduceables” of course is global population. There is simply no way the two and a half billion Chinese and Indians currently living, let alone the next, bigger, generation, can possibly live the same consumerist lifestyle we in the west think is our birthright. The end of the so called Vasco Da Gama Age may involve not just the decline of the western hegemony but wholesale global collapse if all those people want what we think we have.
And what has what we have really brought us except anxiety, envy and an almost terminal sense of our own inadequacies. It’s false consciousness on a monumental, a tectonic global scale.
Politics as a process for realising, directing and protecting cultural and social aspirations has failed or is failing in all manner of places globally and you’d have to say that right here in Oz it’s not looking all that good at the moment. If the latest Neilsen Poll is to be believed we are about to make prime minister a man who just a few short months ago was anathema. I just don’t know what to think about that. I’d have thought I’d be screaming like a banshee but strangely I feel quite detached from it all, not exactly at peace with it, but nowhere near as agitated as I might have thought just a few weeks ago. Not that Abbott is any good. He remains the deeply flawed individual he always was and I don’t think my views on the short odds on electoral stupidity in Oz have changed all that much. I guess it’s just that my expectations, having been dashed once too often on the fatal shore of the local political scene, are now so low, the process so debased and stupid that I can’t even raise the ire I might once have.
Is it that there just isn’t any real mood for redemptive change? Have we lost that capacity? Are we in fact all going to hell in a hand basket? If the answer to any of these is yes then there’s not much I can do individually except, in my own small way, continue to reduce, reuse and recycle, ultimately even the very material fabric of being.
Life never was about a new four wheel drive, a bigger house, a wider screen or a deeper pool. It always was about the family, friends and the moral and ethical constraints in which we should all operate and the political and economic decisions made within those constraints. When I was younger I wanted more and believe me there were times I had as much as I could take; but these days enough really is enough.
Perhaps that’s the problem. The media, having been so successful in trivialising the political process and infantalising the electorate, have consigned us all to a bloated, over sated, hedonistic consumerist doom. Perhaps all this has to collapse before anything good can rise from the rubble. Maybe it does have to actually get as bad as it can get before anyone will believe again in the meaning and purpose of their own existence instead of the brands on everything they own. In the mean time there’s always the going out of business sales.
LikeLike
I am a bit more sanguine about the election but am flabbergasted why the media seem to relish the possible demise of Gillard.
The turn to the right has been terrible in The Netherlands with a cove called Geert Wilders and his PVV ‘freedom party’, a rabid anti-anything foreign but especially Muslims, gaining enormous ground.
Mind you, the figures for numbers of Muslims in the Netherlands are a bit much to absorb and adjust to, even for tolerant Holland.
Amsterdam now has a 27% muslim population, Rotterdam 25%.
Even so, wouldn’t you wish for Abbott to just impale himself on his bicycle seat stem, just once? I am nasty here.
LikeLike
GO, I think that any bike involved with impaling Tony Abbott would need serious counselling, wouldn’t you?
LikeLike
What did you say after sorry?
LikeLike
My little tussle headed hero. Always there to bring us all back to earth.
LikeLike
Earth, the home of the Pigs Arms
LikeLike
Bless you both. There you go. You both blessed.
LikeLike
Warrigal, I have been reading more of your piece and have got to the part where you say “Sorry G” I mean, is this turning? Could you elaborate on Hitler’s rise to power following such a bold observation?
LikeLike
“that it’s taken me…” WM, could you explain why it has it taken you? I mean, are you disabled? Gay? Hypoglycaemic? Auto immune deficient? Lazy? C’mon guy, lettuce us no?
LikeLike
“me so long to read” okay WM, Afrikaans now?
LikeLike
“to read and respond to this thoughtful piece….” what, have you run out of dunny paper? Oh, shit, I’ve just realised, I’m at the Pigs Arms, not Unleashed.
LikeLike
Not all at once . Please form an orderly queue.
LikeLike
Morning GO, bloody cold here in Adelaide this morning. Good story, I agree with what you are saying. Economics will see the end of the human race no doubt however the big problem we face is that most folk would rather go to a Kylie Minogue concert then stop the planet from dying, says it all really.
LikeLike
HOO, we had a nice warm day yesterday and did not bother turning the gas heater on, that Milo loves.
We were in the office posting to Pigs Arms when Milo decided it was time to do something; he dragged me to the living room and looked at the heater. I told him to get lost but of course he came back and ‘told’ Gez to put the heater on!
Gez is more obedient, and on it went!
LikeLike
With all that’s is going on, even cricket scoring seems a blessing. Hey, Hung, will you teach me the basics?
What did you think of that footage, showing J.Howard’s face when the result of that cricket leadership came through?
I felt ambiguous but came good when I reflected on his ‘we will choose who comes to this country etc’.
How are the Pull-Ups? My incontinence is flourishing
LikeLike
Hello GO and the Helvi-tastic,
Yes cold down here in the deep south at the moment.
Cricket is so innately boring that one goes along for the community and the day out.
Yes Gerard, my verbal incontinence continues, every time I speak shit comes out 🙂
Howard is a farce and a bigot and should go away.
LikeLike
I love how you cut to the chase, Hung. If it had been me who posted (as opposed to H), you would have said ‘fuck off” instead of “go away”. And you’d have equally been right !
LikeLike
Thanks boss, trying not to say fuck off any more, might upset someone
LikeLike
Now lads, we don’t want to upset the patrons in the Ladies Lounge!
LikeLike