Helvi Oosterman
Forster was returning to England from somewhere exotic, maybe India, on the boat train, sitting in the dining car, he’s waiting for the breakfast to be served. He wrote about this episode later in Food and Wine magazine; it was 1939.
“At last the engine gave jerk, the knives and forks slid sideways and sang against one another sadly, the cups said ‘cheap, cheap’, to the sauces, as well they might, the door swang open and the attendants came out crying ‘Porridge or Prunes, Sir? Porridge or Prunes, Sir?’ Breakfast had begun.
That cry still rings in my memory. It is an epitome—not, indeed, of English food, but of the forces which drag it in the dirt. It voices the true spirit of gastronomic joylessness. Porridge fills the Englishman up, prunes clear him out, so their functions are opposed. But their spirit is the same: they eschew pleasure and consider delicacy immoral. That morning they looked as like one another as they could. Everything was grey. The porridge was in pallid grey lumps, the prunes swam in grey juice like the wrinkled skulls of old men, grey mist pressed against the grey windows. ‘Tea or Coffee, Sir? Rang out next, and then I had a haddock. It was covered with a sort of hard yellow oilskin, as if it had been out in a lifeboat, and its insides gushed salt water when pricked. Sausages and bacon followed this disgusting fish. They, too had been out all night. Toast like steel, marmalade a scented jelly. And the bill, which I paid dumbly, wondering again why such things have to be.”
Some breakfast that was. We all have been faced with inedible food at times, and Foster’s brekkie has made me think of what has been my most horrid food experience.
If I had been forced to swallow the doughy dumplings mum sometimes added to her otherwise excellent pea soup, I would now have to say that it was that soup. Luckily my darling sister loved the dumplings and allowed me to slip them on her plate when no one was looking.
Having to eat raw oysters for the first time and at a rather formal lunch was scary and somewhat tricky, but a good white makes many unwanted things slide down easily. Then there was that dreadful cook in my primary school, and her even more dreadful food… I think that was IT, and only some warm school milk to assist you to get it down.
What about you, was it tripe, brains..or a crocodile steak?
I’ve said it before, but it’s always worth repeating. I will eat anything that doesn’t run away quickly enough.
I have sat for five minutes after reading the article and all the comments to try to think of anything I refuse to eat. There isn’t any – but I’m not best fond of pumpkin or tripe.
LikeLike
The oldest and youngest menfolk in the Oostie family love watching ‘Man versus Nature’ on SBS. I don’t mind seeing how he builds his ‘house’ for the night but when he starts talking about live grubs and cooked or raw snakes for brekkie, I’m off…
LikeLike
You will recall that Bear Grylls was, for a time, a schoolboy on the IOW. As was Jeremy Irons (born in Cowes).
There has been many a stalwart fellow hail from there.
LikeLike
Don’t forget me!
LikeLike
Jayell, I find the show amusing, just can’t bear to look at Bear’s dinners…
Of course he’s also more of a man than Jeremy, who’s no match for Vectis Lad 🙂
LikeLike
Thank you, Vectis Lad, how careless of me to get the author’s name wrong.
Anyhow, a very cute baby you have there VL
LikeLike
Yes, said grandson: two, Feb 5th
LikeLike
Lumpy porridge & prunes; followed by smoked (done to death) haddock.
One can only dream, sigh!
And ‘Aussie’ (Dame Melba) toast–served in unfortunate circumstance. I can remember that marmalade from boarding school. Oh happy days.
Chitterlings were my worst enemy. I still recoil at the name and would walk from Brisbane to Noosa, if it would avoid one whiff of the vile things.
I feel a gag coming on.
LikeLike
I had to google to find out what chitterlings are, now I too feel a gag coming on…
Living on a farm as a child there were pigs and things slaughtered, blood wurst/sausage and other weird things made: terrines and more…even blood pancakes…enough to make a girl to become a semi vegetarian….
LikeLike
Yet, the pommies at work were, only the other day, lamenting the lack of availability of ‘delicacies’ such as chitterlings, sweetmeats (which I think is thyroid, parathyroid and thymus) and other assorted detritus that belongs in the the fertilizer factory.
LikeLike
BM, thanks for explaining what ‘sweetmeats’ are, I already had to google haddock and chitterlings, almost sorry I did, gagging even more now 🙂
LikeLike
Actually fresh haddock is a delight to eat, but it wasn’t always available in the early 20th century, except close to sea ports.
It was mainly served smoked in the UK, to preserve it; coloured with some sort of yellow dye to give it a more appeasing look.
Too much cooking to something already smoked, would have resulted in a dish exactly as Forster described.
The English cuisine was atrocious-hence the value of spices- and the establishment of herb & kitchen gardens. Traders made fortunes importing nutmeg and pepper ect. But it took a long time to filter into everyday life. In fact probably not till the late sixties.
Of course the opposite is true now with every-one a professed culinary guru.
LikeLike
Vectis Lad, Jamie Oliver went to America to tell the kids what potatoes look like before they become chips, he also taught them how to use forks and knifes. I think they knew about spoons. Too much take-out, eating from cardboard boxes, perhaps…not the kids’ fault.
LikeLike
yo
LikeLike
…got your foot away from the fridge?
LikeLike
lol
LikeLike
True,
Those lamb frenched cutlets used to be my favourites. They are now $2.- each, for just one mouthful.
Still, when you don’t smoke anymore.
LikeLike
Mine too Gez, I will have give up smoking so I can buy some
LikeLike
I never had trouble with oysters, raw or otherwise. We used to go camping at Bendalong before anyone else did and picked them of the rock plateau and with a bit of lemon, mmm. ( We were the sun-kissed undisputed kings of the surf then)
Now Bendalong (Redhead) is peopled by rows after rows of caravans with alum. annexes . Some have put stone lions and ornate plastic edgings along ‘lawns’. No more open fires. Just whipper snipping, leaf blowing and not a rock oyster in sight.
Sticking to food, I’ll eat anything but scooping a spoonful of Vegemite out of a jar still resembles getting a similar coloured sample into a jar with a wooden spatula and taking it to the quack.
LikeLike
True to form, my dear boy, true to form…
LikeLike
I think he’s been berated over at UL for likening our national spread to something more mundane.
LikeLike
As I’ve said before, tripe wins hands down for me – the worst.
Gerard, regarding oysters – when my second daughter was about 7 we all went to a lunch at our club (!) where the menu was a choice of one of three for entree, mains etc. Entree included half a dozen natural oysters and two other things which daughter did not like. I told her to order the oysters anyway. I very much enjoyed my two lots of oysters and put the empty plate back in front of daughter. Waitress came back to retrieve plates and asked daughter how she liked them – cool as cuc she answered ‘they were delicious’. Same daughter is now 24 and prepares and eats oysters kilpatrick – still won’t eat them raw.
LikeLike
…just a dash of lemon juice for me.
I have never eaten haddock, I looked up it’s Finnish name just to be sure; it’s called ‘kolja’, which is also a diminutive form of the Russian name Nikolai.
I’m not keen on anything smoked, I read that haddock is often smoked…
LikeLike
Of course, a nice Dutch raw herring is still my favourite. Went to Holland some years ago and bought 10 of them. I explained to the fish-monger that I just arrived from Australia and wanted to eat some herrings. Quick as a flash, “Yes, I thought you looked a bit pale, in need of some herrings,” he said.
LikeLike
The first time I had the Dancing Squid dish; they’ve cut off his body and slivered it up for sashimi, he lies on the plate, his legs feeling around for the rest of him, eyes bewildered. Sadist that I am, I took subsequent guests to the restaurant and ordered it for them too.
LikeLike
The second specialty I thought were some kind of intestine, somebody hissed “they’re fish penises!” Really good, a citrus dressing.
LikeLike
Grey. And slimey.
LikeLike
The men at the table have shiny uncomfortable eyes when a woman orders them. Like she’s revealed herself as some scary monster.
LikeLike
But they’re really good enough for a second round.
LikeLike
The waitress comes round and takes up the plate with the now languid squid on it. How do you want that prepared? It comes back as a plate of deep fried squid legs. No eyes this time.
LikeLike
Oh Lehan, I have to rush to the bathroom now, anything with the eyes still attached arriving at the table, to eat some-one’s eyes, it’s like eating some-one’s soul , too hard to contemplate…
LikeLike
Yup. You look that sashimi right in the eyes before you start eating it. Very confrontational. If it was always like that we’d soon be able to sort the vegetarians from the fashionistas.
LikeLike
Lehan, life is confronting enough without some eyes staring at you from your dinner plate…
I watched a documentary about obesity on SBS. Two young over-weight English people travelled to South America to find out why there are so many poor fatties over there.
Poverty stricken Paraguayans moved to Argentina and started eating disgusting amounts of meat; practically a whole cow was put on the table…eyes too…
LikeLike
I think the Chinese are admirable for their use of all the parts of the animals they eat. They don’t throw things away. The Japanese used to be pretty good at it too…until they grew a bit rich to bother.
LikeLike
E.M Forster was lucky, at least he would have sat down while eating.
I believe that even more joyless and therefore more desirable, was eating cold boiled cabbage, standing up and in a draught. The dream of many an Anglo.
LikeLike
Now, now, gez, this might just be one-off train food… Still I like how he describes it ; prunes like wrinkled skulls of old men 🙂
LikeLike
Skulls? You say?
LikeLike
Some best chefs now come from England, so things have changed there too.
LikeLike
I was quoting EM Forster, Vectis, he amuses me 🙂
LikeLike
You mean FoRster, the writer?
LikeLike