Is Turkey showing us the Way?
June 18, 2011 by gerard oosterman
Turkey promised to keep their borders open for the people fleeing the violence in Syria. Many thousands of Syrians have crossed into Turkey and footage shows men and women, children walking into that country.
Even though Turkey is a country with a large population of over seventy million and already coping with an overflow of many other nationalities, it has not lost its humanity in doing the right thing by extending its hospitality to those so much worse off. They are quickly opening disused buildings and building camps, constructing a temporary hospital.
If Turkey can do it, where is our compassion?
Lack of ‘humaneness’ is what seems to doggedly divide Australia from most of the rest of the world with a deeply engrained hostility towards others. It is especially directed to those hapless victims of endless wars that somehow managed to make it anywhere near our shores.
Our present minister and previous Government ministers have exalted in, ‘we must make conditions here as harsh as possible as a deterrent’. The general gist of the messages from our Governments has been very constant., “No-one, we repeat, no-one should come here under the understanding they will be treated with compassion or care if they jump the ‘queue’ or come ‘illegal’ by boat,” is what they mainly are saying. The political leaders are well aware that those sentiments will be well rewarded with the approval of thousand of voters.
The latest threat of sending at least 800 refugees to Malaysia just about takes the cake in the manoeuvring of our desperate Government keen to further whip up our xenophobia. The fact that this whipping might be translated to a caning in Malaysia was just seen as a mere bagatelle, easily overcome with a few soothing words of a promise that that would most likely not happen. The UNHCR seems less convinced.
While the conversation is continuing and a flurry of visits to New Guinea and Nauru intending to underline our tough stance once again, some might question where this dreadful fear comes from. Is there something in our history that gives us clues?
We couldn’t do much wrong by visiting our most recent history of how we treated children, both in our mother country of the UK and in our own.
Just having seen the film “Oranges and Sunshine” and previously read D.Hill’s, “The forgotten Children”, I wonder if one day we might admit there was something rotten going on in our culture dating back perhaps hundreds of years. I know of no other country that exported and deported over a 130 000 children in recent times. I also know of no other country that then allowed the further destruction of those children in the institutions they arrived at.
Is it is the history of bullying children and sending them into the hierarchical system of the English Boarding Schools, the Public ( Private) Schools with its whipping masters and the degrading of all those coming into contact with the ‘British system’ of parenting and educating?
This seems to go to the very heart of why Australia has never managed to shake of that bullying that defined us from the very start.
Yet, when it comes to cattle or suicidal whales we all get teary eyed, ban the export of cattle or stand in the sea for days stroking dying whales. Where is the stroking for the flotsam of humans cast on our shores?
Last Monday’s ABC’s 4 corners, again ‘bullying and degrading’ at the very core of our armed forces. It is totally ‘us’ and not just the isolated few of ‘them’. Howard, Ruddock, Abbott, Gillard, Morrison, Bowen. What chance did they all have growing up and indoctrinated into a system of bullying? No Government except the British, conduct parliament so appallingly and again, bullying is at the very heart of it.
In the meantime we should take a leaf out of Turkey’s book. We will not turn them away, is what the Turkish Minister for Immigration is reported as saying. They are human beings in distress.
I can’t even imagine one of our politicians saying that.
Tags: Abbott, Bowen, British, Howard., Private schools, Ruddock, Syria.UNHCR, Turkey
Posted in Gerard Oosterman | Edit | Leave a Comment »
Thank you for this piece Gerard. I despair at the way we treat people trying to seek refuge in this country when so few of them try to enter compared to othe countries. Italy I understand has something like 25000 a month trying to enter Greece 300k a year and the US somethong like 1m, yet this country gets worked up over a few thousand arriving by boat yet ignores those entering by plane.
How did it come to this 40k arriving by boat since the end of the Vietnam war and up until the Tampa they were treated reasonably humanely. With Tampa and Howard stealing an election with his dog whistle it demonstrated that racism was just bubbling along below the surface and had raised its ugly head just like during my youth. From that time on the Liberal party moved from being consevative to basically fascist. Win an election pul out the dog whistle.
Nowadays the Labor party is not much different. Why can’t they just bring these people to the mainland process them here and let them live in the community. I understand this happens in many European countries. At least they can benefit the country as a whole.
In essence the Abbott sickens me and Morrison he is simply frightening. The want to send the poor people to Nauru an island of birdshit 100s of kilometres from nowhere with a population of 11000 to do what send them mad like last time. Morrison is so stupid he doesn’t know when top shut up. Lists his hobbies as going ti church, goodness knows what the church is and has no idea what Luke 10 v30-37 (The parable of the good samaritan) has to say.
The Labor party just needs to bring them here. I’ve employed many refugees who have arrived by boat. All of them have conributed gratly to the common good.
LikeLike
Algernon,
You are right. The number of refugees arriving here is minuscule and this is being blown all out of proportion. The idea of treating people badly in order to prevent them from coming here isn’t sound policy at all. It is primitive and unbelievably ignorant of what makes people so desperate to try anything to escape from war and mayhem.
The idea of processing while they live in the community is what most countries follow. If they are also allowed to work and earn money and pay tax, they would of course become an asset instead of the hundreds of millions of dollars wasted on just a few thousand boat people.
Australia has gone ‘nuts’ over this issue.
LikeLike
I have no doubt that Australia will eventually process refugees/boat-people on-shore. This will happen when our position will become untenable and not because of our Government’s humanitarian concerns. There are just too many that will demand what the rest of the OECD is doing.
Here is what is happening at the moment:
: http://www.abc.net.au/news/stories/2011/06/18/3247293.htm?section=justin
http://www.abc.net.au/news/stories/2011/06/18/3247302.htm?section=justin
LikeLike
Gez, while I’m in absolute agreement with the core of your sentiment about ill treatment of asylum seekers, I am a little bothered with a couple of things in your piece.
I find it, for example, too simplistic and unhelpful the practice of the apposition of two sentiments, worthy of equal empathy, but one being treated as more important than the other. To place, for example, the outrage one feels at the maltreatment of animals, on one side of a balance and that of the maltreatment of human beings on the other and consider that one is more worthy of outrage than the other, is to my mind, a worthless exercise and one which neglects that humane people, sensitive people can feel equally as outraged for both cases. Personally, I am quite capable of seeing the ugly side of both and find the ugliness of both is equally outrageous.
Those who are sensitive will shed a tear not only at the sight of a child being torn apart from its family –or an any adult for that matter- but also at the sight of a poor animal slaughtered in a painful way. Sensitive people will feel deeply for both.
Another thing that I also consider to be simplistic is the view that leading politicians are the true face of the nation they lead. Apart from the fact that there are many types of politicians, some of whom are, indeed, a shameful embarrassment to the people they represent and others a shining light, there are also many types of citizens. I doubt there will ever be a leading politician with whom every citizen will agree on every issue, just as I doubt that every citizen will agree with his neighbour on every issue.
You’re right, the politicians you’ve mentioned are, so far as the issue of asylum seekers is concern, a grand paradigm of the worst type of insensitivity. These are the men and women who would rather show toughness of musculature than toughness of morality. I am very afraid, the whole world is getting more and more that way –leading politicians wise.
As for Turkey.
Well, yes, Erdogan and Davutoglu might have said this and it is all very good for the poor Syrians who are fleeing for their lives but, as for Turkey –Turkey as a political entity and not as its people- it has very little to teach the world about matters humanitarian. Apart from the very questionable treatment of its own citizens, one might want to check with the poor Kurds, or the Armenians or the Cypriots or the Greeks and see what they think about its humaneness.
Of course, I applaud very enthusiastically the utterance and, even more, the deed but let not this single utterance nor this single deed, make us drop our guard when we’re discussing Turkey’s humanitarian philosophy. It has been appalling for many, many years and it is still quite within the vicinity of being appalling.
I might also add, being the incorrigible cynic that I am, that Turkey (again, the political entity and not its people) is desperately seeking to become a member of the European Union and has been knocked back on a number of occasions exactly because of the abhorrence that the member states feel about Turkey’s humanitarian and judicial views and inadequacies. I sincerely hope that this exhibition of magnanimity is not merely an exhibition but a true sentiment towards a persecuted people. I’ll find it easier to believe though, if it treats with similar generosity and fairness its Kurdish people.
You’re absolutely right about the incidents of cruelty in the history of this country, as well as many incidents running currently but these can’t be used as a shroud with which to cover it completely, as if the whole nation –political entity and its people- is well beyond remedy. Quite the contrary. Australian politicians might have let Australia down in many ways but while we’ve got people, like you who keep a sharp eye on their behaviour, Australia is very much redeemable.
LikeLike
Ato:
I agree wholeheartedly with your response and would like to add that this piece concerns itself most with our treatment of boat people/ refugees and when it comes to treating others badly, no country is pure and holy. The massacre at Srebrenica happened while the Dutch UN soldiers were supposed to prevent such a thing from happening, but…… a Dutch prime minister took responsibility and resigned over that.
As for my piece giving animals a treatment different from people! I agree that there are people who would feel equally disturbed by bad treatment of both, but the cattle export to Malaysia was instantly stopped, the outrage was just too strong.
We haven’t seen the same passion about boat-people though, have we? In fact, the xenophobic rants on the different forums indicate that most are happy with the treatment of the boat people.
Of course Kurds are not treated fairly by Turkey nor the Greek Cypriots but so are our indigenous. One can go forever but Australia is unique in that of all the OECD countries we have done so much more to incur the wrath of UNHCR about how we seem to treat the most vulnerable…
I’ll eagerly wait for one of our ministers or prime ministers to resign over bad treatment of the vulnerable. The apology for the ‘forgotten children’ came more than thirty years after we stopped the importation of children from the UK!
LikeLike
We shoot at refugees even when they are not anywhere near us inAustralia. Instead we chase them to Christmas Island and then shoot at them.
You are right though, we should not compare ourselves to Turkey. We are obviously more in tune with Malaysia.
http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=5ab_1172940415
LikeLike
Childish.
LikeLike
All right, Gez.
Obviously you have misunderstood what I was trying to tell you.
I’ll leave it at that.
LikeLike
Ato, Gerard’s reply was to Voice, He wrote it before your wonderful reply. Gez never seems to get his replies in the right place. Just Check the posting times 🙂 He does listen to you and values your opinions!
LikeLike
Didn’t Turkey also take boatfuls of people from Libya, and also from Egypt.
LikeLike
The comparison with the current situation in Turkey is just so ridiculous. The Syrian refugees are fleeing armed troops at short notice to keep themselves and their children alive. The same way you would be fleeing a gunman on the street. The only way to keep them out of Turkey would be to shoot at them. It would be grossly inhumane to let them starve or deny them medical help.
There is every reason to hope that they will only be there for a short time and that they’ll return to their homes asap. Before their camps become a refuge for insurgents against the Syrian government, potentially dragging Turkey into war.
LikeLike
Many Australians have become so heartless that they would either shoot them or let them starve.
LikeLike
Many Australians are murderers. To numerous others, grievous assault is no problem. Many more are thieves. And the Easter Bunny isn’t real.
Of course, Turkey has the same problems. Except they might be less concerned about the Easter Bunny.
LikeLike
Gez, I’ve been reading a bit of Stephanie Dowrick titles “free thinking”. In one section she talks about integrity – in her view it is sometimes expressed in the link between saying and doing. On that basis alone, we can see a massive integrity vacuum on both sides of Australian politics. Sadly for us, the one we had hoped so much for just tells bare faced lies and no lefty worth their dsalt would EVE consider shafting people off with that integrity hole in the ground known as Malaysia. Locking up the opposition leader on allegations of buggery is so 17th Century, isn’t it ?
I’m all in favour of letting people who arrive here the hardest of ways to live and work in the community. (as opposed to Brits overstaying holiday or working youth visas)
Last visit to Melbourne, FM and I took a cab returning from the city to the airport. The driver was a young man from Ethiopia who was living here legally with his wife and child (with another on the way). He was working three jobs. His cabbing was a plug while his preferred hire car driving was held up due to car repairs. Meantime he had just completed an air conditioning technician course at RMIT – and was struggling getting work because he was “too old” to be taken on as an apprentice. His English was impeccable (his father was an engineer – killed in the last conflict with Eritrea). He is a credit to himself, his family and an asset for Australia. And he is optimistic and loves this country because – as he said – ” it’s totally safe. Nobody wants to kill you because of your ethnic background. You can get anywhere here – you just have to work hard and save”.
I agree with you – we may have human rights problems as bad as Turkey in some cases, but we are way way behind them in compassion for refugees.
LikeLike
Yes, Gerard, a very timely piece. I’m one of those who gets teary eyed at the thought of a whale dying on the beach. I also get teary eyed at the thought of a child being incarcerated for doing nothing other than landing on one of our beaches in a rickety boat. Parents lost, perhaps sacrificed themselves so the younguns could have a better life. Of course, if mum and dad were white skinned diggers, or farmers, or pioneers or battlers, we’d be weeping for them, writing poetry, having a sausage sizzle to raise money for the kiddies schoolin’, maybe raise a statue of the drowning parents in the local park.
Instead we lock them up, only to find that, after a few years of this treatment, they revolt, set fire to a garbage bin, or stand on the roof and yell at people. The we want to send the bastards back to where they started!!!
Jeff Biscoe, Hobart Councillor, wants to unleash these asylum seekers into the community so they can work, shop, engage with the locals, and be exposed to great Aussie values. I think he may be the smartest bloke in this country. His detractors seem to think he’s inviting a fifth column of undercover militia to rape our women and steal our cows.
Poor bloody asylum seekers, can’t win, can they??
LikeLike
“Lack of ‘humaneness’ is what seems to doggedly divide Australia from most of the rest of the world …”
See your doctor.
LikeLike
What kind of response is this, Voice ? Ploise explain.
LikeLike
Emmjay, I don’t think that gerard is either ignorant of the rest of the world, or stupid. The only alternative I can see for the assertion is that it’s crazy. There’s no more point in refuting it than there is in refuting someone who asserts that they wrote all of Shakespeare’s plays and their wife wrote the sonnets, but it’s so gratuitously insulting I didn’t want to let it go thru to the keeper.
Why do you ask?
LikeLike
It is politics Voice. And it’s all become too hard, or so it seems. Soften up and you’re to blame for the boats coming. Get tougher, not tough enough. If Abbott and Morrison et al would just bloody well shut up on asylum seekers.
LikeLike
To be honest, I’m ignorant of Morrison. But Abbott in his disconnected bubble world is just plain scary.
LikeLike
The main difference is that when Morrison walks he doesn’t look like he just got off a horse. Both vile. He is their Shadow for Immigration.
LikeLike
Viv, I feel that Scott Morrison is worse than Abbott and Howard put together. I get the feeling that he’s the Liberals’ poster boy, lot of the Libs do not like Turnbull…
No one is perfect but for the short period that Kevin and Malcolm were there, things were a little bit more civil in my humble opinion 🙂
LikeLike
Sending refugees to Malaysia to be cained, makes we feel sad. So did seeing the movie ‘Oranges and Sunshine’.
It’s a good movie tho, and it’s not all sadness, David Wenham is wonderful in it, but as he is my favourite Aussie actor, he is always good in my eyes 🙂
LikeLike